Combat the Abilene Paradox by Identifying Groupthink

Earlier this week, we looked at the Abilene Paradox- a trap that groups often find themselves in when making decisions.  The paradox, a common pitfall of group decision-making, can be identified by looking out for the red flags discussed in the post, but how do you guard against it?

  • Identify Groupthink signals within your organization. Common signals include:
    • Failure to create a plan B
    • Excessive rationalization of decisions
    • Pressure to conform
    • Self-censorship of alternate opinions
  • Make room for disagreement
    • Encourage your people to stand up for their convictions
    • Know how to manage conflict and keep it healthy
  • Avoid language that plays on our tendency to agree with groups, such as:
    • “Is anyone vehemently opposed to this?” Anyone slightly opposed won’t speak up
    • “So we all agree, right?” Instead ask if anyone has anything to add
    • “Where are your pom-poms, Ted?” If Ted offered constructive criticism, he probably won’t do it again
  • Don’t use “rule by committee” where everyone must agree
    • People are incentivized to agree, even if they inwardly don’t believe in the idea
    • Unanimous agreement is rare and requires an inordinate amount of time to reach
  • Re-configure groups
    • Subgroups
    • Different leaders
  • Create avenues for staff to voice their opinion
    • Anonymous Hotlines
    • Ask people on-on one
    • Blatantly ask if it’s a “trip to Abilene”

We all want to avoid pouring our resources into bad ideas. By putting in the effort to root out groupthink, you will not only become a more effective leader, but your team will be more motivated and will have more reason to take ownership of the projects they work on.



What is 6 + 2 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
All fields are required.

Join 60,000 other leaders engaged in transforming their organizations.

Subscribe to get the latest agile strategy best practices, free guides, case studies, and videos in your inbox every week.

Keystone bright-path authority-partners iowa caa maw maryland mc kissimmee dot washoe gulf reno